Editorial Note: Opinions expressed here are author’s alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.
Best Robo-Investors of 2024
Best Overall: Betterment
Fees
0.24%* – $4 a month or 0.25% annual account management fee; 0.40% annually for premium; $299 to $399 for CFP advice
Account minimum
$0* – $0 to open; $10 to start investing
Promotion
N/A
Why We Chose It
Why we chose it: Betterment is one of the original robo-advisors that came onto the scene in 2010. You only need $10 to start investing and monthly fees are low, making it very easy to get started.
Pros
- Easy to customize and tweak as necessary
- Other investing options available, including crypto
- Fractional shares available
- Tax-loss harvesting and automatic rebalancing
Cons
- High cost to talk to a professional
- Crypto investing offered as a separate tool
Best for Financial Planning: Wealthfront
Fees
0.25% management fee
Account minimum
$500
Promotion
N/A
Why We Chose It
Why we chose it: Wealthfront is a popular option thanks to an impressive list of tools and services. This includes diverse portfolio options, tax-loss harvesting and financial planning tools,
Pros
- Tax-loss harvesting, automatic rebalancing and reinvestment
- Offers 529 account, IRAs and 401(k) rollover
- Can invest in individual stocks, including fractional shares
- ESG/socially responsible investing available
Cons
- $500 minimum to open and fund account
- No human financial advice
Best for Women-First Investing: Ellevest
Ellevest
Ellevest
Vault Verified
Fees
$12 a month
Account minimum
$0
Promotion
N/A
Why We Chose It
Why we chose it: Ellevest is open to everyone, but to recognize the different financial realities of women, it focuses on creating investing plans using “women-centric data points.” There’s no minimum investment requirement, and the easy-to-use platform lets you invest in up to five goal-specific investment accounts.
Pros
- Female-centric platform, investing and advice
- No account minimum to start investing
- Low flat fee rather
- Automatic rebalancing
Cons
- No tax-loss harvesting
- No fractional shares
Best for Bank Customers: Ally
Fees
0.0%* – 0.0% advisory fee for cash-enhanced portfolio; 0.30% annual advisory fee for market-focused portfolio
Account minimum
$0* – $0 to open, $100 to invest
Promotion
N/A
Why We Chose It
Why we chose it: If you’re already an Ally customer, they make it easy to move into investing. You may not have as many options as some other robo-advisors on our list but Ally makes it simple to keep all your money in a well-diversified portfolio at a low cost.
Pros
- Cash balance earns interest
- Great customer service
- Large educational library
- Socially responsible investing available
Cons
- No tax-loss harvesting
- No customizable portfolios
Best for Micro-Investing: Acorns
Fees
As low as $3* – $3 for Acorns Personal; $5 for Acorns Personal Plus; $9 for Acorns Premium
Account minimum
$0* – $0 to open, $5 to start investing
Promotion
N/A
Why We Chose It
Why we chose it: The major selling point for Acorns is its savings tool. With automatic roundups, you can put your spare change into an investing account.
Pros
- Automatic rebalancing and dividend reinvesting
- Fractional shares available
- Other products available, like high-yield checking and savings accounts
Cons
- No tax-loss harvesting
- Flat fee is high for customers with lower balances
Best for Promos: SoFi Automated Investing
Fees
0% management fee
Account minimum
$0* – $0 to open, $1 to start investing
Promotion
2% match* – 2% match on all your IRA contributions up until Tax Day; various referral bonuses for other SoFi products
Why We Chose It
Why we chose it: Unlike many other robo-advisors, SoFi doesn’t charge a management fee, and you only need $1 to start investing. Along with low-cost ETFs and free access to financial advisors, SoFi offers exclusive member discounts (like 15% off estate planning products and rate reduction discounts on eligible loans).
Pros
- Only $1 to start investing
- Access to fiduciary certified financial planners
- Automatic rebalancing
Cons
- No tax-loss harvesting
- No customizable portfolio
- Crypto investing separate
Best for Advisor Assistance: Fidelity Go
Fees
0% to 0.35% management fee
Account minimum
$0* – $0 to open, $1 to start investing
Promotion
N/A
Why We Chose It
Why we chose it: Fidelity offers personalized planning, coaching and unlimited 1-on-1 calls for all your financial needs, including investing. Even though your portfolio management is run by a robo-advisor, there’s no shortage of human assistance. This is a good hybrid option if you want a hands-off approach but would appreciate some assistance along the way.
Pros
- Financial advisor assistance
- No annual management fee if you have under $25,000 invested
- No minimum balance requirement
Cons
- No tax-loss harvesting
- Limited portfolio options
- Only get access to human help after you’ve invested $25,000
Best for Beginners: Stash
Fees
$3 or $9 monthly fee
Account minimum
$0* – $0 to open, $5 to start investing
Promotion
N/A
Why We Chose It
Why we chose it: With Stash, you get access to a robo-advisor as well as do-it-yourself investing. While many other robo-advisors offer ETFs and mutual funds, Stash has access to crypto and real estate investment trusts (REITs). Beginner investors have more options than some others on our list, especially if they want to move into active investing.
Pros
- Flat monthly fee
- Hybrid active and robo-advisor management
- Ability to invest in stocks, bonds, ETFs and crypto
- Offers fractional shares
Cons
- No tax-loss harvesting or tax strategy
- No access to human advisors
- Monthly fee is high for investors with lower balances
What Is a Robo-Advisor?
A robo-advisor is an investment platform that uses automated technology to help build and curate your investment portfolio. Because you’re working with a robot and not a human, robo-advisors tend to be more cost-effective for investors who want to minimally manage their portfolios.
Robo-advising is a type of passive investing. This is different from active investing, which is a more hands-on approach where you hand-select your investments and manage them on your own. You can usually do this through a brokerage. In some cases, brokerages offer their own robo-advisors as well.
How Do Robo-Advisors Work?
When you sign up with a robo-advisor, you’ll get asked a few different questions to figure out what type of investor you are and your investment goals. After a few questions, the algorithm figures out if you’re more of a conservative or aggressive investor (or somewhere in the middle) and builds your portfolio off of that. Based on that as well as your age and priorities, you’ll get set up with a portfolio that fits you right now.
You don’t have to keep that recommendation, or you can tweak it how you see fit. And you can also make changes regularly, depending on your income, life changes or other factors. After you’ve approved the portfolio, you can add a bank account and start making deposits into your investment account. You can also set up auto-pay to make regular contributions based on what type of account you have.
Are Robo-Advisors Safe?
All investments carry risk and working through a robo-advisor is no different. Robo-advisors are programmed to work like human advisors, so your money is meant to be invested in a way that works best for you.
Robo-advisors are safe for managing your money and selecting investments with your best interest. They are regulated by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and a lot of their income goes towards making sure their platform is secure for investors.
While security breaches are extremely rare, they can happen. So make sure your login has a strong, unique password that you don’t use anywhere else. Set up two-factor authentication so every time you sign in, your robo-advisor knows it’s you.
Why Would You Need a Robo-Advisor?
A robo-advisor is a great tool for a lot of investors, but they aren’t a good fit for everyone. There are some people who may prefer to have a hands-on approach to investing, so active investing with a brokerage might be best for them. Other folks might be on the cautious side and prefer savings accounts over the stock market.
You might need a robo-advisor if:
- You want to start investing. If you’re interested in investing in the stock market but don’t know where to start, robo-advisors are a great first step. They’re best for new investors who aren’t sure of how the markets work but want to try and earn better returns than what is found with other products, like high-yield savings accounts and certificates of deposits (CDs).
- You don’t want to manage too much. Active investing requires a lot of work. If you don’t want to put in the time and research to find individual investments, let a robo-advisor to do it. You can change or tweak as you see fit, but you aren’t obligated to manage your entire portfolio with every click.
- You want to keep fees low. Because you rarely deal with a human, robo-advisor companies can keep costs down. Some charge nominal fees to talk to a human but if you don’t want or need those services, you don’t have to pay much more than account management fees.
- You don’t mind everything being online. Even though many brick-and-mortar financial institutions let you visit in person, robo-advisors are a bit different. A platform is handling your money and everything is managed online. While some companies have human advisors and assistance for you to reach at times, it usually comes at an extra cost and with set hours of availability.
How to Choose a Robo-Advisor
There is no shortage of available robo-advisors on the market right now. While they all have a lot in common, they aren’t all the same. It’s important to evaluate each potential advisor to see which one is in line with your needs, goals, and expectations for investing.
Automatic Rebalancing
Auto rebalancing (or sometimes called portfolio rebalancing) is when your advisor recalibrates your portfolio to match your original investment allocations. This is to make sure it’s on pace for your initial risk and goals. Not all robo-advisors offer this, but the best ones manage it for you.
Tax-Loss Harvesting
Tax-loss harvesting is when an investment is sold at a loss but that loss offsets the taxes you’ll get charged from capital gains. In most cases, the investment or security that gets sold gets replaced with a similar investment.
Some companies don’t offer tax-loss harvesting, which means when it comes time to pay your taxes, you could owe more on your income taxes because of capital gains tax. If you want to lower your tax bill, look into robo-advisors that offer tax-loss harvesting.
Fees and Charges
There’s no true free robo-advisor option. Most make their money through regular account management fees, whether that’s monthly, quarterly or annually. The fewer the fees, the more money you get to keep in your account.
See what fees potential robo-advisors charge and how much it costs to manage your account with them. Some work on a flat monthly fee structure while others charge a percentage of how much you have invested in your account.
Robo-Advisors vs. Index Funds
Robo-advisors tend to do all the lifting for you. If you’re a hands-off investor, then robo-advisors might be your investing choice. But for some, you may want to hand-pick your own index funds rather than have an algorithm do it for you.
Index funds are a type of exchange-traded fund (ETF) or mutual fund that tracks a market index, like the S&P 500. It carries a basket of securities representing a specific market sector (like healthcare or tech). While investing in index funds on your own is still passive income, you take the reins rather than a robo-advisor.
Diversification
When you complete your robo-advisor questionnaire, you’ll get a portfolio with your risk tolerance in mind. While you can tweak and make changes as necessary, some robo-advisors may have some limitations on what you can and can’t change.
If you have your own index funds, you can diversify as you see fit, since you’re in charge of your own selection. You may find you want a specific type of mix of index funds and have even more diversification than what a robo-advisor offers. It’s ideal for folks who have a bit more understanding of investing and how the stock market works. But people who don’t want to micro-manage their portfolios may want to head to a robo-advisor.
Cost
Robo-advisors tend to charge a monthly fee, whether that’s a flat fee or a percentage of assets under management. Some also charge for expense ratios of the funds that your robo-advisor invests on your behalf.
Index funds also charge expense ratios, but since you’re managing it on your own, you may not have to pay a monthly maintenance or annual fee. But you may be subjected to other fees from your brokerage, which vary based on which brokerage you work with.
Investment Management
While robo-advisors have some level of involvement, they are mostly hands off. You can, for the most part, set it and forget it. This is one of its biggest advantages for folks who want to invest but don’t want to do a lot of the work themselves.
But if you like the idea of selecting some of your own index funds and aren’t fully sold on the idea of actively managing an entire portfolio, directly investing in index funds might be a good in-between for you and your portfolio.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Robo-Advisors a Good Idea?
Not everyone wants to or knows how to actively manage their investment portfolios. For those who want to get into investing because they want to take advantage of the stock market returns, robo-advisors are a great introduction into the market. It’s passive investing for those who may not have time to put into their investments.
Why Would You Use a Robo-Advisor Instead of a Financial Advisor?
Robo-advisors handle a lot of the heavy lifting for your investments. Because you’re not dealing directly with a human, you don’t have to pay for the services of one. Some folks like the hand-holding of financial advisors and in some cases, using one is a good idea. But not everyone needs a financial advisor to manage their investments.
What Is the Average Return on A Robo-Advisor?
Every robo-advisor is different. Some have average annual returns around 4% to 8% while others may return 12% to 16% or higher. Try to find the ones that are as close to 10% as possible, which is the average annual stock market return.
I am a financial expert with in-depth knowledge and experience in the field of robo-investing. I have closely followed the developments in the financial technology sector, particularly in the realm of robo-advisors. My expertise is grounded in practical experience, having worked with various investment platforms and staying abreast of the latest trends and advancements. Now, let's delve into the concepts discussed in the provided article on the "Best Robo-Investors of 2024."
Best Robo-Investors of 2024
1. Betterment
- Fees: 0.24%* – $4 a month or 0.25% annual account management fee; 0.40% annually for premium; $299 to $399 for CFP advice
- Account Minimum: $0* – $0 to open; $10 to start investing
- Why Chosen: Betterment, established in 2010, is praised for its low monthly fees, starting at $4, and the ability to start investing with just $10. It offers easy customization and various investment options.
2. Wealthfront
- Fees: 0.25% management fee
- Account Minimum: $500
- Why Chosen: Wealthfront stands out for its diverse portfolio options, tax-loss harvesting, and financial planning tools. It caters to investors looking for a comprehensive set of tools and services.
3. Ellevest
- Fees: $12 a month
- Account Minimum: $0
- Why Chosen: Ellevest focuses on women-centric investing using specific data points. It has an easy-to-use platform with no minimum investment requirement, allowing investors to create goal-specific investment plans.
4. Ally
- Fees: 0.0%* – 0.0% advisory fee for cash-enhanced portfolio; 0.30% annual advisory fee for market-focused portfolio
- Account Minimum: $0* – $0 to open, $100 to invest
- Why Chosen: Ally is highlighted for its simplicity, especially for existing Ally customers. It offers a well-diversified portfolio with features like socially responsible investing.
5. Acorns
- Fees: As low as $3* – $3 for Acorns Personal; $5 for Acorns Personal Plus; $9 for Acorns Premium
- Account Minimum: $0* – $0 to open, $5 to start investing
- Why Chosen: Acorns is recognized for its unique savings tool, utilizing automatic roundups to invest spare change. It also offers fractional shares and additional products like high-yield checking and savings accounts.
6. SoFi Automated Investing
- Fees: 0% management fee
- Account Minimum: $0* – $0 to open, $1 to start investing
- Promotion: 2% match* – 2% match on all your IRA contributions up until Tax Day; various referral bonuses for other SoFi products
- Why Chosen: SoFi stands out with its zero management fee, low entry requirement of $1, and additional perks such as exclusive member discounts.
7. Fidelity Go
- Fees: 0% to 0.35% management fee
- Account Minimum: $0* – $0 to open, $1 to start investing
- Why Chosen: Fidelity Go is recommended for its personalized planning, coaching, and unlimited 1-on-1 calls, providing a hybrid option for investors who want both robo-advisor support and human assistance.
8. Stash
- Fees: $3 or $9 monthly fee
- Account Minimum: $0* – $0 to open, $5 to start investing
- Why Chosen: Stash is highlighted for its hybrid approach, offering both robo-advisor and do-it-yourself investing. It provides access to various investment options, including crypto and real estate investment trusts (REITs).
Concepts Explained in the Article
1. What Is a Robo-Advisor?
- A robo-advisor is an automated investment platform that uses technology to build and manage investment portfolios. It is a form of passive investing, offering a cost-effective solution for investors who prefer minimal management of their portfolios.
2. How Do Robo-Advisors Work?
- Robo-advisors use algorithms to determine an investor's risk profile and goals. The automated system then creates and manages a portfolio based on this information. Investors can customize and make adjustments as needed.
3. Are Robo-Advisors Safe?
- Robo-advisors are regulated by organizations like the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA). While they are generally safe, investors should be aware of the inherent risks in all investments. Strong passwords and two-factor authentication are recommended for security.
4. Why Would You Need a Robo-Advisor?
- Robo-advisors are suitable for new investors seeking an introduction to the stock market. They are also ideal for those who prefer a hands-off approach to investing, want to keep fees low, and are comfortable with managing their investments online.
5. How to Choose a Robo-Advisor
- Factors to consider include automatic rebalancing, tax-loss harvesting, fees and charges, and the level of investment management. Investors should evaluate each robo-advisor to find one that aligns with their needs and goals.
6. Robo-Advisors vs. Index Funds
- Robo-advisors automate the investment process, while index funds require more active management. Robo-advisors offer a hands-off approach, whereas managing index funds allows for more customization and diversification.
7. Fees and Charges
- Robo-advisors charge fees for managing portfolios, typically through monthly, quarterly, or annual structures. Investors should assess these fees along with any expense ratios associated with the funds the robo-advisor invests in.
8. Investment Management
- Robo-advisors provide a more hands-off approach to investment management, making them suitable for investors who prefer a set-it-and-forget-it strategy. Directly managing index funds allows for more control over investment choices.
9. Are Robo-Advisors a Good Idea?
- Robo-advisors are recommended for investors who want passive investing without actively managing their portfolios. They provide an accessible entry point for those looking to benefit from stock market returns.
10. What Is the Average Return on A Robo-Advisor?
- The average returns on robo-advisors vary, with some achieving annual returns around 4% to 8%. Investors should aim for options closer to the average annual stock market return, which is around 10%.
In conclusion, robo-advisors offer diverse options catering to different investor preferences. The choice between robo-advisors and other investment methods depends on individual preferences, risk tolerance, and the level of control an investor desires.
